The Height of a Presidential Campaign
Forget the inflammatory remarks, the controversial statements or “The Scream.” A political pundit close to AfterW.org recently developed the theory that Howard Dean’s 2004 campaign for the White House was doomed from the start. Why?
Not freakishly short, but certainly not tall. At 5′8″, Dean is still in the ballpark as far as American men his age are concerned. But, according to our analyst, that’s not exactly presidential. AfterW.org founder, M. Levi Bluefield, concurred, stating:
“You can’t be president if you’re 5′8″.”
Can you?
Dean lost the nomination to John Kerry, who towered over him at 6′4″. Coincidence? Probably not. Howard didn’t exactly help himself by remarking that the capture of Saddam Hussein didn’t make the U.S. safer (correct as he was) or numerous other gaffes in the days before the Iowa caucuses.
But the Presidential Height Index suggests there’s something to this hypothesis. Since the rise of television in American homes, the tallest candidate has won the popular vote in every election but three: the 1972 defeat of 6′1″ Sen. George McGovern by 5′11″ Richard Nixon, the 1976 loss by Gerald Ford, a six-footer with two inches on Jimmy Carter, and Kerry by George W. Bush, who’s also an even six.
If you consider 1960 the dawn of televised politics - as our expert does, claiming the tube almost single-handedly delivered the election to John F. Kennedy - the taller candidates are 9-3. Not a shabby record. What does the theory hold for 2008, when only the strongest of the contenders in this marathon campaign are left standing (pun intended)?
Currently, the candidates with the biggest height disadvantages are, interestingly, the early frontrunners in both parties. The Dems’ early leader in the polls, Hillary Clinton, is listed at 5′6″ or 5′7″, depending on what you read, while Republican John McCain is only 5′7″.
Not sure if these Senate heavyweights would relish a debate against the other, but at least height would be a non-factor. Interestingly, if either wins the White House, they’ll be the shortest chief executive in an even 100 years (Teddy Roosevelt, who served from 1904-1908, was 5′8″).
As for Dean, the former Vermont governor and current DNC chairman, he says he never had a complex about his average stature. He actually mentioned his height on the campaign trail in 2003:
“I’m 5′8″ … almost 5′9″ … actually 5′8″ and three quarters. But the reason I don’t tell anybody about the three-quarters is that it sounds like I’m very sensitive about my height. And I’m not!”














